The Grace of the Law

T

Ernest Kevan, The Grace of Law (London: Carey, Kingsgate Press, 1964). Also republished by Soli Deo Gloria (2003).

The relationship between Grace and Law, as they relate to the life of a believer, has been a frequent issue of tension in theological history and practice.  This has a bearing on how we view the proper of relation between Justification and Sanctification, the place of good works in the life of a believer and the polar dangers of Legalism on the one hand and Antinomianism on the other.  In the medieval period the Roman Catholic Church adopted a view where the believer’s obedience to the Law of God was meritorious and thus a component part of his Justification before God. At the Reformation, the Protestant Church rejected this and recovered the Biblical doctrine of Justification by faith alone, but there were different views between the Lutheran and Reformed Churches in the relationship between the Law and the Gospel. In the seventeenth century, Grace and Law again became contentious in the Antinomian controversy which, among other things, undermined the role of good works in the believer’s life of sanctification. Others, such as Richard Baxter ran to an opposite extreme to teach what is known as Neonomianism that included the believer’s new obedience in his justification before God.

Although these controversies are old, they are sadly ever new, and we encounter them in various forms within the Reformed and Evangelical Church today.  Some press a false distinction between Law and Gospel too far and tend toward an Antinomianism which is quick to call all striving after obedience in the Christian life, Legalism. The rise of “New Covenant Theology,” which views the whole of the Old Testament Law to have been abrogated and New Testament obedience to be unto a new “Law of Christ” in the Spirit, though not absolutely Antinomian in itself, certainly has tendencies toward it.  While on the other hand, a form of Neonomianism which errs in the direction of the Roman Catholic heresy on Justification, was resurrected by Norman Shepherd in the 1980’s and incorporated into what became known as “The Federal Vision” in the first decade of the new millennium.    

To obtain clarity on these perennial issues no one volume is better suited than Ernest Kevan’s excellent work “The Grace of Law.” It is a study of the seventeenth century debates around Antinomianism and Neonomianism in which he guides the reader through the main issues with honesty, letting the participants speak for themselves and demonstrating how our Puritan forefathers brought the teaching of the Bible to combat both errors.  The work is an amazing accomplishment, published as it was in the early 1960’s at a time prior to the renaissance of Puritan literature we take for granted today through publication houses such as the Banner of Truth.  The extent of Kevan’s reading in the source material and the arrangement of the subject matter is itself worth considerably more than the price of the book in itself.

The author begins by setting the scene in the Puritan era of the seventeenth century and introducing the major parties in the debates and outlining their views and the issues at stake in the controversy. He then moves in chapter two to the Law of God treating God’s sovereign right to command, the Law of God in the heart of man at creation and the affect of the Fall upon this internal moral transcript.  Next He deals with sin in relation to the Law, showing that it is fundamentally law breaking and therefore the Law is the instrument of convicting man of sin, both in the experience of the unbeliever and believer, in whose experience sin still remains sin. In Chapter three he opens up the “Place of Law in the Purpose of God,” introducing the threefold division of the Law in its ceremonial, Judicial and moral aspects before treating how the Law functions in connection with God’s Covenant both in both the Old and New Testaments, and the relationship of the Law to the Gospel.  

Chapter four focuses on how Christ is the “End of the Law for Righteousness” to the believer. Kevan examines how the active1This is the obedience of Christ in His entire life of conformity to the Law of God, doing always and only that which pleased the Father in heart and life, in thought, word and deed. and passive2This is the obedience of Christ in suffering death and the wrath of God to make an atonement for the sins of His people. Though called his ‘passive obedience,’ He was active in it in that he ‘laid down his life’ willingly and obediently. obedience of Christ is imputed to the believer in justification and shows how this by no means abrogates the commanding aspect of the Law to Christians as a rule of obedience as the Antinomians taught. He also shows how the Mosaic Law relates to the “Law of Christ” in the continuation of the same moral law for the New Testament disciple. While we are dead to the Law as a covenant of works, we are not dead to the law as a rule of life. This is further fleshed out in chapter five where the Law’s continuing moral obligation in Christian obedience is asserted against the Antinomian rejection, together with the place of divine threatenings and promises of reward.

Chapter six examines the subject of “Christian Law Keeping” and our need for a rule of obedience rather than mere internal heart inclination. In other words, we still need to know what God commands. It is here that Kevan most thoroughly interacts with the erroneous excesses of Richard Baxter’s Neonomianism. He shows how good works are evidence of grace in the Christian life and how those works, though imperfect, are pleasing to God who graciously accepts and rewards them.  Chapter seven outlines the true doctrine of Christian Freedom. While we are obligated to entire obedience, this is not legalism but the fruit of Redemption, Regeneration and the indwelling of the Spirit of Christ. The believer is active in this obedience not passive as the Antinomians taught, so that although given all grace to keep the Law, our obedience is still properly our own. We work out our salvation in fear and trembling, yet we do so through the operation of the Spirit who makes us willing and able to obey (Phil 2:13-14). Therefore, Christian obedience is not legalism, but the very antithesis of it. He concludes “The Puritans believed that the highest spirituality was to be seen in a life that rejoices to be commanded.”3Kevan, Grace of Law, p.249 As the Psalmist says, “I will walk at liberty, for I seek thy precepts” (Ps 119:45). Consequently, obedience to God’s Law is true freedom, not bondage and holiness is our true happiness.

The final chapter summarizes the Puritan view of the Grace of Law and assesses it in the light of more recent critical study. Kevan evaluates its Biblical method, ethical principles, theological foundation and soteriological4Soteriology is that aspect of theology that deals particularly with the doctrines of our salvation by Christ. interest, over against the errors of legalism and Antinomianism. After this follows a “Select Bibliography” of source material which includes around two hundred and ninety primary source works written by one hundred and twenty authors; with another two hundred secondary source books and articles.  These works are quoted from copiously throughout the book, indeed many sections are an amazing arrangement of Puritan writings over against those of their opponents and they succinctly prove Biblical truth over against its contrary errors.

In an age of many books it is important to read the best books on the most relevant subjects. There are too many books out there that are little help in redeeming the time God has allotted to us in this life. Kevan’s work is one of those “must-read” books. It is difficult to recommend it too highly. It will help the reader understand his own spiritual experience correctly and motivate him from a full and free Justification in Christ to an earnest life of obedience to the Law as the fruit of his justified state. It will likewise aid in the discernment of so much theological and practical error that has flooded even conservative Reformed Churches in our day and enable him to plough a straight course and keep to the path of Biblical, Reformed and Evangelical Christian godliness. We commend it to all our readers, and especially all those who hold office in the Church of Christ.

Footnotes

  • 1
    This is the obedience of Christ in His entire life of conformity to the Law of God, doing always and only that which pleased the Father in heart and life, in thought, word and deed. ↩︎
  • 2
    This is the obedience of Christ in suffering death and the wrath of God to make an atonement for the sins of His people. Though called his ‘passive obedience,’ He was active in it in that he ‘laid down his life’ willingly and obediently. ↩︎
  • 3
    Kevan, Grace of Law, p.249 ↩︎
  • 4
    Soteriology is that aspect of theology that deals particularly with the doctrines of our salvation by Christ. ↩︎

About the author

Jonathan D. Mattull (1981-) serves as minister of Sovereign Grace Presbyterian Church (FCC) in St. Louis, Missouri. He is a native of St. Louis, and a graduate of Missouri Baptist University and Covenant Theological Seminary.

Recent Posts

Popular Tags